Final Fantasy IX: Somewhere Between Borefest and a Rat Breed of Dragoon Knights [Archive] - Anfiniti Network

PDA

View Full Version : Final Fantasy IX: Somewhere Between Borefest and a Rat Breed of Dragoon Knights


ZombieG
05-01-2007, 10:21 PM
Is it just me, or does any Final Fantasy installment always get rave reviews the week it comes out? It's only until a few months afterward when people come back down to the actual plane of gaming existence that they realise they've been had. Essentially, Final Fantasy has done that to us since Final Fantasy VII, and Final Fantasy IX is not that much better.

I don't pretend to be any sort of RPG veteran, but the Final Fantasy series is one that I am particularly familiar with. The game has always been based around fantastical settings, occasionally delving into the world of sci-fi with mixed results here and there. However, it seems that Final Fantasy have become too afraid to venture away from one story progression to the point where every new release makes it that much more cliched. It's always a love story between two unwitting and usually out-classed characters hindered by some mundane fact set against a story of political intrigue, and somewhere along the lines, you're given a twist that redefines the central character's take on existence. This same story is present in Final Fantasy IX. Except this time around, you're Zidane, a failure of a ladies' man who is part of a group of thieves named "Tantaulus." You're sent on a mission to kidnap the princess of the nation of Alexandria, Garnet. Guess what the ensuing adventure leads to?

Of course, the cliches don't end there. You'll meet up with a cast of characters whose attitudes are recycled from past characters. You've got the cold, silent type much like Shadow from Final Fantasy VI, Vincent Valentine from Final Fantasy VII, and Squall, the central character from Final Fantasy VIII. The "I swear revenger!" character much like Loki from Final Fantasy VI, and of course, someone always vows to protect someone else. Now we're at the point where you can formulaicly create a Final Fantasy before it hits the market.

While, Final Fantasy IX's system is a bit of a return to form from the intensely mathematical stylings of Final Fantasy VIII, there is a lot left to be desired in over-all game-play. Such obstacles exist in the system where, say you have a sword that inflicts poison(Which is another gripe, there are millions of status effects on Final Fantasy IX, a lot of which are pretty much the same thing with a new name...) and you equip this on Zidane. Your sword cannot inflict poison unless you have added the "Add Status" ability to your current catalogue of useable abilities. Minor things like this can be an extreme hindrance to a plan of combo'd abilities.

Beyond the system, there are moments where Final Fantasy IX will make you want to kill yourself from being so brain-numbingly anti-"Giving-you-any-help-at-all." For instance, you'll be stuck in a mountain path or dungeon against monsters strong versus elemental attacks, and you're stuck with one physical fighter, two white mages and Vivi, the black mage. Naturally, the player thinks: "I'll just change my party." Incorrect, in Final Fantasy IX, you start being able to actively select your party on the third disc. Which means, farming produces extremely unbalanced groups of characters. Your level 30 team with Zidane, Garnet, Eiko and Vivi will reunite with Steiner, level 19, and Freya, level 21. Add that to a game that seems like it's too short to reach level 60 by the end of the game, and in the end it kind of seems like your RPG abilities have been capped.

However, all this is not to say Final Fantasy IX doesn't have it's upsides. For instance, the card game is amazingly fun. Without a doubt, the most addicting part of the game, hands down. Other than that, the return to a more fantastic theme gives your characters an extremely unique appeal. One of my favorite characters for instance, is Freya, the rat-woman Dragoon Knight. Though, part of her story is extremely disappointing, she remains one of the more, if not the most useful character in the game, next to Steiner who is a major dolt and blunderbuss of a musclehead.

In the end, all of Final Fantasy IX's pitfalls score it an average rating. While, most consider it a return to form for Final Fantasy because of a consistent theme regeneration, it tends to bore more often than it does amaze, and can be quite a hindrance in some portions of the game. Definitely has a bit of personality, though. I've rarely heard a character use "poop" as a derogatory insult before.

(6/10)

Grim Oyster Kvlt
05-01-2007, 10:24 PM
Extremely nice review. You seem to be good at em! :)

Anyway, I entirely agree on all points made.

Ehsivar
05-01-2007, 11:11 PM
You have to admit, some of the landscapes and areas were really neat. Memoria is a piece of art to me, personally.

Grim Oyster Kvlt
05-01-2007, 11:17 PM
Actually yeah, that much is true. FFIX had some of the best scenery in the whole series, by far.

Zaben
05-01-2007, 11:19 PM
I actually enjoyed the storyline in FFIX far more than the storyline in most of the FF games.

Grim Oyster Kvlt
05-01-2007, 11:38 PM
well, FFIX's story was better than VIII's, or everything after it. But, FFVI still had the best story imho.

Ehsivar
05-01-2007, 11:39 PM
I can't find Memoria pictures...x__x

Atmasaro
05-01-2007, 11:44 PM
I enjoyed the review, regardless of my lack of agreement with it.
I think the majority of the appeal in the Final Fantasy series actually lies in the thematic elements. They use the same plot device each time to emphasize a new theme. In that way, FFXII was probably a breath of fresh air as it changed the plot device while still keeping the thematic genius.

As for FFIX, I think it was one of the strongest thematically. It wasn't so much a love story as it was a story of life and the quest for meaning.

I guess I take the literary stance on most things. Regardless, I see why many people might feel a little ripped off by the glorious reviews of the Final Fantasy series. As far as gameplay and plot originality, it's never been the upper crust.

ZombieG
05-02-2007, 02:36 AM
Glad to hear you enjoyed it, Atmasaro.

I see what you're saying with the figurative undertaking of the game, and that's all fine, but then you have to take the underlying figurative stance on all of them, which is still pretty much inter-changeable. For instance, Final Fantasy VII was as much about the fight to maintain life as Final Fantasy IX was, as they're facing a pretty much world-wide apocalypse.

NanakiXIII
05-02-2007, 09:23 AM
I actually enjoyed the storyline in FFIX far more than the storyline in most of the FF games.

I agree with Zaben. FFIX was one of my favorites. It has it's flaws(I won't even get into the trance system going off whenever you are fighting the rat right before the big boss) like most games, but overall, it's highly enjoyable.

Ehsivar
05-02-2007, 08:39 PM
I can't really say that I have any major complaints with the game. I loved every minute of it, and I'd play it another four times.

Zaben
05-02-2007, 09:16 PM
I agree with Zaben. FFIX was one of my favorites. It has it's flaws(I won't even get into the trance system going off whenever you are fighting the rat right before the big boss) like most games, but overall, it's highly enjoyable.

Oh god, that's so damn annoying. Or, when I finally do get a trance in a boss fight, I have to waste the turn doing something like reviving Zidane because his stupid ass got killed at the worst possible time.

ZombieG
05-02-2007, 09:39 PM
The Trance system blew. Amarant and Steiner were especially useless, as was Eiko.

It always seemed like it sapped power from Freya's jump whenever she went into trance. One attack might do 500 damage to every opponent. By the end, it's down to 72.

NanakiXIII
05-03-2007, 09:09 AM
The Trance system blew. Amarant and Steiner were especially useless, as was Eiko.

It always seemed like it sapped power from Freya's jump whenever she went into trance. One attack might do 500 damage to every opponent. By the end, it's down to 72.

I thought the Steiner/Vivi combo was amazing. I usually ran with Zidane, Garnet/Eiko, Steiner, and Vivi.

Chaos Bard
05-03-2007, 10:45 AM
Ahahaha, decent review. I liked the game and I could still see where you were coming from.

Personally, I found that the game was good fun in small doses, just like Legend of Dragoon. I tended towards Zidane/Amarant/Steiner/Vivi, just because you didn't NEED a healer with that much potent ass-kickery. Granted, I never beat the game without cheating: I found a sort of curse in that everytime I got to disk 3 or 4, my file would get erased while I was leveling up. So I gameshark'd and finally beat the game; found all the ends tied quite nicely.

Overall just not bad. Played far better, played far worse.

ZombieG
05-03-2007, 06:02 PM
I thought the Steiner/Vivi combo was amazing. I usually ran with Zidane, Garnet/Eiko, Steiner, and Vivi.I found Steiner just way, way too oafish. What a goober. Completely turned me off to him.

I usually go with a party of Zidane, Amarant, Freya and Garnet, as her summons were usually attack-based. Eiko is mostly support summons, and who the fuck needs regen on all characters for a measely 55 HP or so per turn? Waste of time.

Freya held an embargo on all the bad-ass, though. Just throwing that out there.

Ehsivar
05-03-2007, 08:51 PM
I wish they'd introduce Freya's race in other games. They just had to call her a Burmecian.

Atmasaro
05-05-2007, 07:06 PM
Glad to hear you enjoyed it, Atmasaro.

I see what you're saying with the figurative undertaking of the game, and that's all fine, but then you have to take the underlying figurative stance on all of them, which is still pretty much inter-changeable. For instance, Final Fantasy VII was as much about the fight to maintain life as Final Fantasy IX was, as they're facing a pretty much world-wide apocalypse.

You're right. FFIX and FFVII both contained themes of life. I personally think that IX was different in that it was about life's purpose on an individual basis whereas VII took on the extermination of life as a whole.

Either way, I can see where FF can get redundant EVEN figuratively.
Strangely enough, I guess I'll just always be a fan.